2011 was the year of the Irish golfer. Witnessing the vulnerability, humility, fortitude, and grit displayed through our beloved sport was revitalizing — it’s almost as if a level of purity was brought back to the game.
The media focus on the Irishmen raised a greater curiosity into the native land churning out these immensely talented, yet down-to-earth characters. I still can’t decide if I’d rather get their autograph or catch the next pint-filled card game. Even their cherry-looking agent was refreshing. Regardless, it’s indisputable that 2011 was the year of Irish-born golfers so when I had the chance to review 18 Greatest Irish Golf Holes it was met with excitement.
My exposure to Irish golf has been limited to Tralee, Lahinch, and Waterville; this was many years past — Lahinch before they redesigned it to the original MacKenzie days. Obtaining 18 Greatest Irish Golf Holes is like having one of New York’s finest steaks served to you…but you’re only allowed to eat two bites before having it removed from your table. Reader beware, after reading 18 Greatest Irish Golf Holes you will want to go there — this is a simple warning and I’m sure a small percentage of the author’s intention was to evoke such a feeling.
The authors (Craig and Andrew) do a phenomenal job of representing the culture of Ireland. Like the country, it’s welcoming — not stuffy — well-informed, with a splash of showmanship to drive, rightfully so, the point that Ireland has some of the best golf in the world. Ireland’s diverse conditions are represented throughout the mesmerizing photography sprawling the pages…it’s painfully inviting.
The name brands average golfers will know are covered such as Ballybunion, Lahinch, and the K Club. However, this book doesn’t rest on Ireland’s most storied clubs, through design analysis and course strategy it educates the reader as to why they’ve chosen holes on courses that may not be known even to the truest of golfers.
My greatest contention with the book is the author’s belief that a hole’s value is barely altered due to its historical importance. Applying similar logic, one could argue some of the U.S.’s finest courses lack the maturity and expertise of a contemporary architect and therefore shouldn’t be held in as high esteem. This stance prompted me to re-read their introduction and they masterfully address their reason:
“Historical importance has no bearing on judging the quality of a hole yet profundity, if not the ghosts of golfers and Architects past, counts for something.”
However, I still place a higher regard on a hole’s ghosts than the authors, but appreciate their stance because the reader is exposed to the fundamental best holes and courses.
Minor contention aside, a reader will leave 18 Greatest Golf a more informed golfer, a desire to travel to Ireland, and a belief that perhaps Ireland does have some of the greatest golf in the world.
{ 2 comments }














